New Research Shows Legislation To Boycott ESG May Cost State Taxpayers Up to $700 Million in Excess Payments

As several states consider new anti-sustainable investing initiatives, new analysis shows taxpayers in six states could have been on the hook for up to $700 million in excess interest payments, if restrictions on sustainable investing had been in place. State officials and state legislatures have either passed or will consider bills and initiatives based on a piece of model legislation developed by the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), part of a coordinated conservative effort to prop up the fossil fuel industry while putting retirement nest-eggs at risk.   

“The firefighters’, school teachers’, and municipal workers’ in these Republican controlled states are the folks suffering from the actions of their elected officials” said As You Sow CEO Andrew Behar. “The legislators who passed these laws, forcing state treasurers to boycott financial institutions that have historically funded their municipal bonds, has led to reduced competition, a waste of funds, and an overall breach of trust. The fundamental job of a treasurer is to evaluate risk; including environmental risk, social risk, and governance risk. Legislators will face the backlash of their constituents for flushing hundreds of millions of dollars down the toilet for their own political games.

"This report highlights the potential multi-million-dollar economic burden on both residential taxpayers and businesses in states that are taking or considering actions to limit climate and other ESG considerations within their municipal bond work," said Steven M. Rothstein, Managing Director, Ceres Accelerator for Sustainable Capital Markets. "These actions will increase costs and interfere with the free market in states that move forward."

Until now, the costs associated with anti-sustainable investing legislative and executive initiatives to taxpayers has been relatively unknown. The ‘ESG Boycott Legislation in States: Municipal Bond Market Impacts’ study expands on a previous study by the Wharton School of Business that found significant financial impacts—potentially upwards of $532 million in additional interest payments—of recent legislation to Texas taxpayers. It uses the findings of that study to anticipate costs to six states that have passed or are considering similar legislation and directives. 

The new data finds that taxpayers in Kentucky, Florida, Louisiana, Oklahoma, West Virginia, and Missouri could have faced upwards of $708 million per year in additional interest charges on municipal bonds, if Texas-like restrictions had been in place. The higher interest rates are the result of less competition between finance firms for municipal bonds, as a result of the anti-sustainable investing legislation that forces state treasurers to boycott major banks and asset managers that historically have bid on the muni bond issuances.

The analysis found the aggregate increase in interest costs for the bonds issued in the analyzed states in the last 12 months are as follows:

_{*Because the average maturity of Oklahoma’s bonds was less than the time to Texas’s first call, the lower bound is the same as the upper bound}

In addition to higher interest rates on municipal bonds, the anti-sustainable investing directives and legislation also have the potential to inflict serious economic harm on state and local citizens’ in other ways. The study’s authors identified three other areas where significant costs and financial harm may occur in addition to the municipal bond market that include: 

• State and local treasury functions 
• Pension investment performance
• Government banking functions 

This analysis, like the Wharton study, focuses only on the municipal bond market impacts.

The Sunrise Project, on behalf of As You Sow and the Ceres Accelerator for Sustainable Capital Markets, commissioned economic and policy consultant firm Econsult Solutions, Inc. (ESI) to use the econometric analysis of Texas and its findings to provide estimates of the potential financial impacts on taxpayers.

ABOUT THE SUNRISE PROJECT
Driven by the imperative of climate justice, The Sunrise Project helps to scale social movements to drive the transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy as fast as possible.

ABOUT AS YOU SOW
As You Sow is the nation’s leading shareholder advocacy nonprofit, with a 30-year track record promoting environmental and social corporate responsibility and advancing values-aligned investing. Its issue areas include climate change, ocean plastics, pesticides, racial justice, workplace diversity, and executive compensation. Click here for As You Sow’s shareholder resolution tracker.

ABOUT CERES 
Ceres is a nonprofit organization working with the most influential capital market leaders to solve the world’s greatest sustainability challenges. The Ceres Accelerator for Sustainable Capital Markets is a center within Ceres that aims to transform the practices and policies that govern capital markets in order to reduce the worst financial impacts of the climate crisis. It spurs action on climate change as a systemic financial risk—driving the large-scale behavior and systems change needed to achieve a net zero emissions economy. For more information, visit ceres.org and ceres.org/accelerator and follow @CeresNews.

ABOUT ECONSULT SOLUTIONS, INC.
Econsult Solutions, Inc. (ESI) provides businesses, public policymakers, and non-profit organizations with consulting and thought leadership services in economics, real estate, transportation, public infrastructure, development, public policy and finance, community and neighborhood development, planning, as well as litigation support. Our work represents our commitment to driving positive, lasting economic change, and building stronger communities in measurable ways. We leverage the skills and expertise of our staff and senior advisors to deliver unique solutions to our clients’ most complex challenges and design practical recommendations that deliver tangible value. For more information, visit www.econsultsolutions.com 

Media Contact: Helen Booth-Tobin